Match Report: West Ham 1, Aston Villa 0

Not a great start for Brett Holman (AVFC)

Goals: Nolan, 40 (Vaz Te, assist)

Shots: West Ham – 7 (1 on target); Aston Villa 13 (2)

Possession: West Ham – 34 %; Aston Villa – 66 %

The first match in the Paul Lambert era at Aston Villa and the first back in the Premiership for West Ham ends up being a pretty dull affair, with West Ham grabbing the three points thanks to a Kevin Nolan goal that was initially flagged for offsides. Aside from that goal, neither team really threatened to score. It was a bit of a weird alternate universe thing for Villa fans, who are usually accustomed to defending and looking for occasional counterattacking opportunities, but this time had the lion’s share of possession but couldn’t break down a well-organized West Ham defense. It remains to be seen whether Villa will be more of an attacking force against teams that play more open, expansive football, but on the evidence of this, they won’t unless the bring in a few more players.

Player Ratings

Shay Given, GK – 6; Didn’t have much to do except for the one goal, which wasn’t his fault

Nathan Baker, D – 6; Defended reasonably well, but didn’t offer any width at all in attack

Ron Vlaar, D – 8; Solid at the back. Even got a cut and bled everywhere, which is always a good sign for your central defender

Ciaran Clark, D – 7; Occasionally shaky, but didn’t do anything that led to a goal, which is good enough

Matt Lowton, D – 6; Showed less of the willingness to get forward than he did in preseason matches

Karim El-Ahmadi, M – 7; Combined well with Stephen Ireland, particularly in the first half, but had a few bad giveaways as well

Fabian Delph, M – 6.5; Looked a bit nervous initially, but had a couple uncharacteristic runs into the attacking half, which is a hopeful sign

Stephen Ireland, M – 7; Probably the most forward-thinking Villa player, but none of his through balls or shots came to anything

Charles N’Zogbia, M – 5.5; Another disappointing performance from N’Zogbia; you have to wonder how much longer he will start when he plays like this

Brett Holman, M – 5; Runs around a lot; unfortunately, looked more tentative than he had in preseason and put in a couple woeful crosses. Must be better.

Darren Bent, F – 6; Never got the ball, so it’s hard to give him a rating. Had one shot which was blocked. Needs better service. Same old story

Andreas Weimann, SUB – 6; Didn’t get the ball enough to do anything

Gary Gardner, SUB – 5.5; Didn’t impress when he had the ball

Barry Bannan, SUB – 6; Didn’t do much with the ball after coming on as a sub

Grade: C-. Opening day matches are always iffy – particularly in away games – but on the basis of this performance, Lambert has a lot to do to turn this team around, injuries or no. They passed the ball around well, but didn’t seem to have any idea what to do when West Ham was defending. Baker was fine defensively at left back, saving a certain goal late on, but offered nothing supporting the attack. N’Zogbia and Holman ran around a lot but offered zero penetration. Must be better.

About these ads

Posted on 2012/08/18, in Match reports, World football and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

  1. Big Villa Fan and love the player ratings. Watched only part of the game on a terrible sopcast feed. I get the feeling you know what you’re talking about so will return to read more match reports if written. For me it’s the same as last season. KEA is a good start but we need a Barry/Milner replacement and a complementary striker to Bent would be good. We still have Gabby and Marc to come back but who wouldn’t love to see Johnson in a Villa Shirt as he’s pure quality. Lichaj and Herd are good players and could be the answer at the fullback positions. Unfortunately unless they prove us wrong the verdict on Gardner, Delph, Bannan in midfield is overrated academy prospect and Holman, Nzgobia and Ireland(although he undoubtedly is trying) also need to prove their doubters wrong with performances. No doubt in my mind we are one more centre mid and striker away from a top half finish but Randy needs to bring in two more players to prove to Villa fans and Lambert that he means business. AV4Life. Ronnie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 126 other followers

%d bloggers like this: